Hong Kong Politics & Protest

Ex-leader CY Leung says he is not threatening press club over pro-independence speaker, amid fresh protest

Former chief executive Leung Chun-ying has denied threatening the Foreign Correspondents’ Club, but said that many would want the FCC to explain why the government should not allow others to bid for its Central premises.

Leung, now a state leader, has been criticising the club after it announced it would host pro-independence activist Andy Chan at a luncheon talk next Tuesday. HKFP first reported last Friday that the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Hong Kong had attempted to block Chan from speaking. Leung compared the event to giving terrorists a platform.

Leung previously claimed the Club paid a “token rent” for its Lower Albert Road building. But the claim was debunked by Chief Executive Carrie Lam who said the FCC paid a market rent, with ex-FCC board member Francis Moriarty saying the rent was around HK$550,000 per month.

Leung Chun-ying

Leung Chun-ying. Photo: HKFP.

Local and foreign press groups have said Leung should stop threatening the FCC. Citing a report on Wednesday’s Hong Kong Economic Journal, he responded on Facebook: “The press groups should know that Victor Mallett [sic], the First Vice President of the FCC does not see my comments on the Club’s premises as a threat.”

Leung has shifted his focus to criticise the lease that was granted to the FCC by the government without a public bidding process, despite the lease offer being made during his tenure as the city’s leader. On Tuesday, he said that it was “not the normal process,” as he urged the FCC to disclose the full lease of their club premises.

“So are we being told that severing Hong Kong from China can be the topic of a luncheon talk but the government lease of the premises is out of bounds?” Leung wrote. “Many in Hong Kong would be interested in FCC’s argument as to why other prospective tenants offering government equal or better terms should be excluded from bidding for the premises.”

“I have heard that many non-profit seeking bodies, as ‘unique’ as the FCC might be, have been looking for sizeable club premises in prime Central (5-minute walk from the golden intersection) for the rent that FCC is reportedly paying Government. Is this a ‘threat’?”

fringe-club-foreign-correspondent-club-2

Foreign Correspondents’ Club. Photo: GovHK.

According to the FCC board’s minutes, the latest lease offer from the Government Property Agency was received on August 10, 2015, whilst Leung was in office. It is renewed every seven years.

Leung went on to defend the actions of the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Hong Kong. He said Hong Kong enjoys freedom of the press and freedom of speech as stipulated by the Basic Law, but it also has responsibilities, including those under Article 23.

Article 23 stipulates that Hong Kong “shall enact laws on its own to prohibit any act of treason, secession, sedition, subversion against the Central People’s Government, or theft of state secrets, to prohibit foreign political organizations or bodies from conducting political activities in the Region, and to prohibit political organizations or bodies of the Region from establishing ties with foreign political organizations or bodies.”

Chan Ho-tin

Andy Chan, convenor of the Hong Kong National Party. Photo: HKNP/Facebook.

“These are the clear and absolute ‘red lines’. The rights that Hong Kong enjoy do not override the Article 23 responsibilities,” Leung said.

However, the controversial security law has yet to be enacted as its legislation failed in 2003 following mass protests.

Free speech protest

A group of around 30 pro-Beijing protesters marched from Central’s Chater Garden to the FCC at noon on Wednesday demanding the cancellation of the Andy Chan talk.

fcc protest free speech

Photo: Johan Nylander.

Lau Chong-him, convener of Real Hongkongers View, said Hong Kong independence violates the Basic Law and there should be no room for discussion.

fcc protest free speech

Photo: Johan Nylander.

Lau said the group will consider further action if the talk was not cancelled. Asked if the government should take back the premises, he said the public should consider whether issues violating the Basic Law should be discussed at government premises.

“I’m afraid social disobedience and chaos will break out if we allow talk of independence,” spokesperson Jason Lam said. “I support freedom of speech but it comes with limitations and responsibility.” He added that the FCC building should be up for tender when the contract runs out.

fcc protest free speech

Photo: Johan Nylander.

Also on Wednesday, at a joint press conference at the legislature, several civil groups said the FCC should be able to invite any speakers it wishes, as they criticised Leung’s comments.

“Leung’s actions – intervening in the operations of the FCC – harm Hong Kong’s freedom of speech and freedom of the press, [and] severely harm Hong Kong’s international image,” their statement read.

Neo Democrats District Councillor Roy Tam said Leung’s demand for the FCC to reveal its lease terms was unreasonable, and Leung should first reveal all documents surrounding his own UGL controversy.

“If he can’t do this, he is not convincing anyone,” Tam said. “It is very ironic that Hong Kong chief executives do not defend freedom of speech, but it is rather defended by the FCC.”

ugl cy leung chun ying july 1

Photo: Dan Garrett/HKFP.

Last month, the police told the government that there was a sufficiently strong case in the interests of “national security, public safety, public order, protection of freedom and rights of others” for the security secretary to ban the Hong Kong National Party, citing the Societies Ordinance.

See also: Explainer: How Hong Kong is seeking to ban a pro-independence party using existing national security laws

Chan was asked to respond to a 900-page dossier, which contained 700 pages of his speeches and events collected by police over two years, by September 4.

Additional reporting: Johan Nylander.

Ex-leader CY Leung says he is not threatening press club over pro-independence speaker, amid fresh protest