Hong Kong Law & Crime Politics & Protest

Hong Kong District Council election: Pro-democracy candidate complains problematic ballots were accepted as valid

Ballot counting procedures in Hong Kong’s Lam Tin constituency are in doubt after the pro-democracy candidate complained that problematic ballots had been accepted as valid, causing him to lose the race.

Fung Tak-sum, an independent candidate, was running against Kan Ming-tung of the pro-Beijing Federation of Trade Unions (FTU) in Sunday’s District Council election race.

Ballot counting lasted until 1pm on Monday – around 15 hours after the election officially ended – with candidates requesting multiple recounts. Dozens of residents also gathered outside the counting station in protest.

Fung Tak-sum

Fung Tak-sum. Photo: Stand News.

Fung told reporters that he lost by a margin of 50 votes, but there were over 100 problematic ballots. Fung won 4,030 votes, whilst Kan received 4,080 votes.

Fung said the problematic ballots considered valid included those with two to three ticks inside the box, ticks being stamped on the FTU’s logo, or ticks on Kan’s face as shown on the ballot.

“There were never any guidelines saying that these ballots should be counted as valid,” Fung said.

Fung said he asked for a review of the ballots after it was announced he had lost, but the Electoral Affairs Commission (EAC) – an independent body managing the election – said it was not possible.

riot police

Riot police outside a Lam Tin counting station. Photo: Stand News.

Around ten masked riot police officers then arrived at the counting station to escort the ballots away, as per a request by the EAC, according to Fung.

“Is this a fair election?” he said.

He added that the result was not important to him personally: “What’s more important is for Hong Kong to win.”

藍田選區泛民候選人馮德森以 50…

Posted by Stand News 立場新聞 on Sunday, November 24, 2019

Fung said he will consider filing an election petition.

The election on Sunday saw a record high turnout of 71.2 per cent, with 2.94 million Hongkongers casting their ballot.

The pro-democracy camp enjoyed a landslide win, totalling 389 seats – seizing control of all but one of the District Councils. The pro-Beijing camp obtained 60 seats.


Hong Kong Free Press relies on direct reader support. Help safeguard independent journalism and press freedom as we invest more in freelancers, overtime, safety gear & insurance during this summer’s protests. 10 ways to support us.

fundraising fundraise banner

Hong Kong District Council election: Pro-democracy candidate complains problematic ballots were accepted as valid