Hong Kong Politics & Protest

China seizes on Catalonia unrest to bolster condemnation of Hong Kong protests

By Jing Xuan Teng

China is seizing on violent protests in Europe and South America to bolster its condemnation of pro-democracy demonstrations in Hong Kong and defend its handling of the unrest.

Recent clashes in Chile and Spain’s Catalonia region have added fuel to China’s claims that Western governments and media have hypocritically supported Hong Kong’s protests even while condemning violence at home.

Catalonia Spain Hong Kong protests

This photo taken on October 18, 2019 shows a protester kicking a firecraker during clashes near the Police headquarters in Barcelona, on the day that separatists have called a general strike and a mass rally. Photo: Josep Lago/AFP.

Chinese state media and officials have been weighing in on the unrest abroad in recent days.

“We see violence today in Hong Kong being reproduced in other places,” Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi told AFP on Monday, citing the clashes in Catalonia and Chile, as well as protests in London.

“In Catalonia, they publicly declare that a second Hong Kong will be created in Catalonia and that they are inspired by what’s happening (in Hong Kong). I think some people must think about their actions,” he said.

China has decried “terrorist-like” actions by a violent minority among protesters in Hong Kong and accused foreign governments of fomenting unrest in the semi-autonomous southern city.

Hong Kong’s police force has faced accusations of committing abuses during nearly five months of increasingly violent protests in the financial hub.

October 20 mask ban china extradition protest

Photo: Studio Incendo.

The movement, which was originally focused on opposition to a now-scrapped extradition bill that would have allowed residents of the city to face trial in the Communist-ruled mainland, has now expanded to include broader demands for democracy and investigations into police violence.

“In recent months we’ve seen both Beijing and Chinese state media coming out very strongly against the protesters, painting them as villains in the unfolding drama,” said Adam Ni, a China researcher at Macquarie University.

Beijing is using the situation in Catalonia as evidence that “only with a strong central government, strong law enforcement, can we stay afloat above this sea of chaos”, Ni said.

“It’s basically saying, look, what we’re doing is not that different from what’s happening overseas including in liberal democracies,” Ni said. “But, of course, the context is very different.”

‘Western hypocrisy’

Many in Catalonia who took to the streets after Spanish courts sentenced separatist leaders to lengthy jail terms over a 2017 independence bid have cited the demonstrations in Hong Kong as a source of inspiration.

October 20 mask ban china extradition protest

Photo: Studio Incendo.

Tactics popularised in Hong Kong – such as the use of yellow hardhats and using boarding passes to bypass airport security checks – have been met in Barcelona with tear gas and rubber bullets fired by Spanish police.

In Chile, more than a dozen people have died in violent protests and looting that started because of a metro fare hike but turned into anger against the military and President Sebastian Pinera.

The arrest of protesters in London from environmental pressure group Extinction Rebellion have also been held up in Chinese state media as an example of Western double standards.

“Exposing Western ‘hypocrisy’ has been a common tactic of Chinese state media reporting for quite some time, especially when it comes to security and human rights,” Maria Repnikova, a professor at Georgia State University, told AFP.

In using this tactic, state media is “also indirectly legitimising a harsher approach to Hong Kong”, said Repnikova, who researches political communication.

Embed from Getty Images

Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said on Monday that Western governments’ responses to demonstrators in Catalonia and London showed that “so-called democracy and human rights are only a sanctimonious pretext for the West to meddle in Hong Kong’s affairs.”

‘Exporting revolution’

The foreign ministry’s remarks have been echoed by commentaries and reports in state-run media drawing parallels between events in Hong Kong and elsewhere.

The nationalist tabloid Global Times said in an editorial on Sunday that “Hong Kong demonstrators are exporting revolution to the world in an unexpected way”.

“The West is paying the price for supporting riots in Hong Kong, which has quickly kindled violence in other parts of the world and foreboded the political risks that the West can’t manage,” the Global Times wrote.

October 20 mask ban china extradition protest

Photo: Studio Incendo.

Shen Yi, an academic at Shanghai’s Fudan University, hit out at Western support for Hong Kong’s protesters in a commentary published by the party-run People’s Daily.

“Suppose these people support the Catalonia protesters, the result will be an unstable society; and if they don’t, they are applying double standards to the Hong Kong and Catalonia problems,” Shen wrote.

Chin Yik Chan, a lecturer at Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University, told AFP state media “haven’t changed their tone in the last one and a half months after they defined these demonstrations as violent, as riots, as seeking independence.”

But recent examples of unrest overseas have “reaffirmed their position”, Chin said.


Hong Kong Free Press relies on direct reader support. Help safeguard independent journalism and press freedom as we invest more in freelancers, overtime, safety gear & insurance during this summer’s protests. 10 ways to support us.

fundraising fundraise banner

China seizes on Catalonia unrest to bolster condemnation of Hong Kong protests