Hong Kong Politics & Protest

Pro-Beijing lawmakers vote to unseat democrat James To from leading discussion of Hong Kong’s extradition bill

Pro-Beijing lawmakers have tried to oust democrat James To in a bid to regain the upper hand at the legislative process of Hong Kong’s controversial extradition bill.

The House Committee – which is in charge of the legislature’s internal matters – voted to issue guidelines replacing To with lawmaker Abraham Shek from the pro-Beijing Business and Professionals Alliance.

James To

James To presiding over the bills commitee meeting for the extradition law update. Photo: inmediahk.net.

To had been presiding over the bills committee responsible for vetting the government’s proposal to revamp Hong Kong’s extradition laws. The pro-Beijing camp accused To of delaying the election of the committee’s formal leadership, which made discussion of substantive issues impossible.

Chief Executive Carrie Lam previously asked the legislature to pass the extradition bill by summer, but democrats have expressed dissatisfaction about the bill’s content as well as the government’s tactics. The bills committee has held two meetings – totalling four hours – over the course of a month.

On Saturday, the House Committee convened an emergency meeting to address whether To should continue in his role. Before a formal chairperson is elected for a bills committee, it is common practice for the meeting to be led by the most senior lawmaker present.

house committee

The legislature’s House Committee meeting on Saturday. Photo: Apple Daily

Lawmakers voted 37-19 to oust To, following a rowdy four-and-a-half-hour meeting that was interrupted multiple times.

However, democrats have said that the guidelines were non-binding and that they will not observe them at the next meeting of the bills committee, scheduled for Monday.

“They are using the ‘tyranny of the majority’… they are providing ammunition to us, because there are a lot of things within these guidelines we will discuss on Monday,” said pro-democracy camp convenor Claudia Mo.

“The pro-Beijing camp lawmakers are basically trying to dictate Legco,” Civic Party leader Alvin Yeung added.

claudia mo alvin yeung

Lawmakers Claudia Mo and Alvin Yeung. Photo: Holmes Chan/HKFP.

Connie Fung, the legislature’s legal advisor, said it was up to the bills committee to decide how to interpret the guidelines. Fung added that there were no formal rules on whether the most senior lawmaker will continue to preside over the meeting.

DAB lawmaker Starry Lee, who chaired Saturday’s meeting, drew the ire of democrats by limiting each lawmaker’s speaking time. After facing strong opposition, she ejected lawmakers Claudia Mo, Gary Fan, Wu Chi-wai and Ted Hui.

Lee said the pro-Beijing camp’s actions were “within the rules of the legislature,” and defended her decision to expedite the meeting.

legco protest

Photo: Holmes Chan/HKFP.

Outside the legislature, over a hundred protesters gathered to watch a live-stream of the meeting. Most attendees showed up in support of the pro-democracy camp, and booed pro-Beijing lawmakers when they spoke.

The legislature’s secretariat was criticised by the rally’s organiser after it asked for a TV wall to be taken down over security concerns.


The Hong Kong Free Press #PressForFreedom 2019 Funding Drive seeks to raise HK$1.2m to support our non-profit newsroom and dedicated team of multi-media, multi-lingual reporters. HKFP is backed by readers, run by journalists and is immune to political and commercial pressure. This year’s critical fundraiser will provide us with the essential funds to continue our work into next year.

funding drive press for freedom

Pro-Beijing lawmakers vote to unseat democrat James To from leading discussion of Hong Kong's extradition bill