Domestic Workers Hong Kong Law & Crime

‘I feel lost’: Fired cancer patient exposes plight of Hong Kong’s domestic workers

The case of a Filipina domestic worker in Hong Kong who was sacked after being diagnosed with cervical cancer — leaving her without healthcare — shines a light on the exploitation of tens of thousands of foreign women who toil as maids in the wealthy city.

Baby Jane Allas

In this picture taken on March 5, 2019, Baby Jane Allas, a 38-year-old mother of five Filipina domestic worker who was sacked after she was diagnosed with cervical cancer, cries during an interview with AFP in Hong Kong. Photo: Anthony Wallace/AFP.

A single mother of five, Baby Jane Allas was just 38 when she was diagnosed with stage three cervical cancer in January.

Embed from Getty Images

Then came a new gut punch — a letter from her employers terminating her service, and with it any hope of getting her medical expenses covered under Hong Kong law.

“Reason(s) for termination (if any): Diagnosed with cervical cancer,” read the letter, which was seen by AFP.

Allas was floored. Her firing was likely illegal and she is launching a challenge. But once sacked she instantly lost the right to healthcare — and had just two weeks to leave the city.

“I want to finish my contract… because I have five children, only me, I am (a) single mother,” Allas said, her voice breaking as tears ran down her face.

Embed from Getty Images

Women like Allas are the bedrock of Hong Kong’s households.

Nearly 370,000 domestic helpers work in the city — mostly poor women from the Philippines and Indonesia — often performing menial tasks for low wages while living in poor conditions.

City authorities say the system is fair and that abuses are rare.

Embed from Getty Images

But rights campaigners say domestic helpers are routinely exploited, with laws providing them little protection.

Local rights group Justice Centre Hong Kong estimates as many as 1 in 6 maids work in conditions that constitute forced labour.

Embed from Getty Images

Last year, the US State Department placed Hong Kong on par with Thailand and Afghanistan in its annual human trafficking rankings partly because of the lack of protections offered to maids.

 Easily exploited 

Experts say steep agency fees, a requirement for maids to live with their employers, a minimum monthly wage of just $575 and rules that require fired domestic workers to quickly depart the city leave maids acutely vulnerable to abusive or unscrupulous employers.

Embed from Getty Images

Allas spent just over a year working for a family of Pakistani origin who ordered her to perform tasks even on her one day off each week.

She was routinely given stale leftovers to eat and slept on a thin comforter in a cluttered store room, she added.

“My neighbour… gave me noodles, she is very nice to me, she said, oh what happened to your body, you are so delicate now, only one year you lost your weight,” Allas recalled.

Embed from Getty Images

AFP reached out to her employer for comment but she did not respond to phone calls and messages.

In contrast Allas’ sister Mary Ann was more fortunate.

She landed a job with an American, Jessica Cutrera, who has since taken Allas in, helping her to fight her case and starting an online fundraising campaign to pay her medical bills which has so far raised some US$43,000.

Embed from Getty Images

Cutrera wrote on the campaign’s site that her family would “happily employ her ourselves but she cannot be hired under a new contract with an active advanced cancer diagnosis”.

“We have obtained support to pursue an extended visa while she fights her claim, but this visa will not allow her to access government paid care”.

‘Prevalent discrimination’ 

Allas has filed a complaint with the labour department and her visa extension has given her a temporary reprieve while she fights her case. The department told AFP it would provide “appropriate assistance”.

She has also filed a complaint with the Equal Opportunities Commission which declined to comment on the case but said it is unlawful to dismiss an employee on the grounds of their disability.

“There remains prevalent discrimination against employees who have to take leave for their disabilities or to undergo medical treatments,” it added.

Under Hong Kong law, employers must cover helpers’ medical expenses and are advised to take out insurance.

Embed from Getty Images

But Cynthia Abdon-Tellez, general manager of Mission for Migrant Workers, said ultimately “it is the responsibility of the government to ensure migrant domestic workers have access to public healthcare” regardless of employment status, because cases of wrongful termination are not uncommon.

Mary Ann said she felt “broken” by her sister’s plight and has sought to support her with her own earnings which exceed the minimum wage.

As Allas faces an uncertain future — racked by disease and fear — she hopes the authorities will stand up for women like her.

“I feel lost.”


Editor’s note: Baby Jane Allas’s crowdfunding campaign is running at GoGetFunding.com

'I feel lost': Fired cancer patient exposes plight of Hong Kong's domestic workers